The text is kind of hard to read because there is some difficult words and when you look at it, it looks like a novel. It is very seriously written and kind of boring, with long sentences and no slang. The language is very formally. The theme is death penalty and why he thinks it's wrong, and if our topic in class wasn't death penalty I don't think the text was very relevant to me. I think the article is more relevant to school work and debates about the death penalty, because Fred E. Foldvary certainly is against the death penalty, and means that if a criminal is in jail he isn't a threat to the society. I think the intention with the text is to make a debate about the topic and that he wants to tell how he feels and why. In the text he writes a lot of very good arguments, which make the reader against death penalty, for example that the murderer isn't a threat anymore when he is in jail, and that the victims don't get the person back even though the murderer dies too. So his arguments are very strong, and that makes it a good article. I don't know if the article is reliable because I don't know where it's from, but because he is a Senior editor somewhere, it could be reliable but I really don't know.
Thursday, August 11, 2011
Abolish the death penalty
The text is an article written by Fred E. Foldvary, who is a senior editor. The text is about death penalty, and when it's okay to kill a person and the only time it's okay to do that is if it's self-defense. He writes about the 4 purposes of punishment. The first one is to protect the society, like if a criminal is a threat to the society he needs to go to jail. The second one is to try to change the criminals mind, so when he gets out of jail he doesn't want to harm anybody. The third reason is to scare other of doing the same crime and number four and the last reason is trying give the victims something back. Like if it's a thief who stole something from the victim, the victim needs to get it back or a replacement, but killing the murder vil not bring anything back. He writes that killing a murderer is wrong and will not help anyone. If the government can decide who should live and who should die, it send a wrong message out to the population. Because if the government can decide a man should die because of what he have done, maybe someone would think he could kill a man because of what the man have done, like hitting on his wife or hurting someone he cares about.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment